Nationalism and Ethical Idolatry.
March 12th, 2009
I was a teenager in the early 90’s and back then I didn’t have access to the Internet and its multitude of pirated music. No, back in those days I inserted a blank cassette into my bulky sony stereo, pressed the record button during a radio chart show and just walked away. Not a very sophisticated solution (but hey it worked!) and I inevitably ended up with 40 minutes of bad early 90’s pop music, a lot of commercials and around two full news updates. But my laziness reaped undeserved rewards because a decade later I found these old cassettes pleasantly nostalgic and so played them regularly.
There was however one particular news story that would startle me whenever the disembodied voice of the news broadcaster read the details. The story concerned an IRA bomb that exploded in a Belfast chipper killing ten people. These days, the event is little more than a footnote in the history books but whenever that news program was played, the sheer futility and cowardliness of the act would startle me anew. Occansionally I forgot the story was an old recording and would think to myself “What?! That is STILL happening?”
So when I heard the radio news this morning, my first thought was to check the tape deck for an old recorded cassette from the 90’s :-
The two victims were collecting a pizza delivery at the Massereene base near Antrim when the gunmen pulled up in a vehicle and opened fire.
Four other people, including two pizza delivery men, were wounded in the shooting.
After an initial burst of gunfire, the attackers shot the victims as they lay on the ground. The two soldiers killed were in their 20s and due to fly out for duty in Afghanistan.
These are the first soldiers killed in Northern Ireland in nearly 12 years. The two critically wounded pizza delivery men are apparently deemed legitimate targets for “collaborating with British rule”. Those familiar with this conflict will not be too shocked by this stupidly. Young Irish girls have been shot for dating British soldiers and suspected collaborators were executed in their beds - all for the grand goal of a united 32 country Ireland.
Thankfully these murders were condemned by most parties north and south of the border and by most posters on the popular Irish politics forum Politcs.ie. (I would recommend reading the link for reaction as the news story unfolded).
The nationalists however were unrepentant. Here is a snapshot of the nationalistic responses:
I can’t find it in myself to be sympathetic. I hate anyone being dead but foreign soldiers on my land? Sorry, despite the British newspapers that run our land I cannot sympathise.
But by christ , regardless of the endless snivelling ive read here from poor excuses for Irishmen im proud of our boys tonight . I know we’ll all be feckin interned by this time next week and some of us will be assassinated by ordes special forces in retaliation , but someone made one hell of a stand against the dirty stinking occupation of my country tonight and im damn feckin proud of them . I was out tonight with my neighbours and ive never seen morale as high in years .
god love the rest of yes , hope your pillows arent too damp from the sobbing
Rest easy mate….no irish soldiers fell in this attack….was only brit soldiers fell…….like dominoes from what i hear
Roll on next week when some fenian taxi driver gets 5 in the head
Ethical Idolatry.
I am an Atheist. I am an Atheist for multiple reasons but perhaps most importantly, I am an Atheist simply because there is no good argument for the existence of the Christian/whoever God. However, I do find the theologian concept of idolatry useful as a ethical thinking tool. Allow me to explain.
Ethical Idolatry is the worship of a value or idea itself, instead of striving for the goal of human flourishing.
Values are important. They define who we are as individuals; how we view the world and ourselves; and in some cases, the meaning we give our lives. Values must be subjected to human reason. They must explicitly identified, poked, prodded, molded and humbled by reason.
However the corruption occurs when a value becomes dogma and placed beyond honest inquiry, guarded by layers of protective offense taking, group polarisation and ad hominem attacks. The value itself becomes an all important source of self-identify and self esteem. The actual goal and original purpose of the value is forgotten or becomes a rationalisation for unsupportable extremes.
The environmentalist who would rather protect a rock formation than the people who are living on that rock, is worshipping the value not the goal. The politically correct ideologist who rushes excitedly to defend every racial minority simply because they are a minority, is worshipping the idea, not the goal. And the nationalists who support this attack is worshipping the idea, not the goal. Two men died and four were seriously injured because a handful of idiots did not approve of the colour of a flag flying over a building.
Ethical questions must be aimed at ensuring both communities in the north can coexist peacefully and are not condemned to a endless circle of murder and retaliation. A good start would be a move away from the harmful identity politics of nationalism and religion in favour of an more rational humanitarian approach.
Ironically, I suspect we will see an united Europe before an united Ireland.